Thursday, May 24, 2012 65° - Binghamton, NY

Discover Pipe Dream With Your Friends

Explore the news that your friends find interesting. Connect with Facebook to share your reading activity.

Tragedy calls for animal law reform

Lions and tigers and bears, oh my!

On the afternoon of Tuesday, Oct. 18, more than 50 exotic, and even some endangered, animals were purposely let out of their cages to journey off. The animals had been kept on a private farm owned by Terry Thompson, just outside of Zanesville.

Sadly, Mr. Thompson sought to let his animals roam free just before he took his own life. This tragedy of nearly 50 dead beautiful creatures began with the death of Mr. Thompson and the extremely lax laws of Ohio.

The sheriffs and deputies of the Muskingum County Police Department have received a great deal of criticism for killing the animals. Many questions have been raised as to why the officers did not try to tranquilize the animals or force them into an enclosed area before resorting to a massacre of wildlife.

As members of the Muskingum County Police Department have stated, their main concern was the safety of Zanesville’s citizens.

“These animals were on the move and were showing aggressive behavior,” said Muskingum County Sheriff Matt Lutz.

Unfortunately, according to Sheriff Lutz, there was no time to waste.

Unlike the majority of public opinion, I believe that these officers did the right thing. Although it is heartbreaking, I can only imagine the multitude of lawsuits and mass anguish to follow if one of the animals attacked and killed a citizen. People are simply pointing fingers in the wrong direction.

Members of the Muskingum County Police Department are not the ones to blame; they did what they could in a time-sensitive situation. The real perpetrators are Ohio’s lawmakers. The state’s specific law regarding private possession of exotic animals states, “No person may bring into the state a non-domestic animal unless the possessor: obtains an entry permit; health certificate certifying the animal is free of infectious diseases; and a certificate of veterinary inspection.”

Ohio is one of few states in the United States that offer any alternative to a strict no-possession policy of exotic animals. But by no means does a certificate of possession or a veterinary health inspection validate one’s responsibility for the lives of exotic animals or one’s responsibility for the danger those animals pose to everyone around them.

As sadly proven, Ohio’s requirements for possession of exotic animals are too lenient. In addition to the inspections of the animals, inspections of the prospective owners should also be required. Owning large animals that are aggressive by nature should be scrutinized just as carefully as owning a gun.

It is unfortunate that this grievous event had to occur at all, but thankfully, because of it, it will not happen again. New legislation is now progressing in Ohio that, when passed, will be effective immediately. Named the House Bill 352, it would “ban all future ownership of dangerous exotic animals, defined as, but not limited to, big cats, nonhuman primates, alligators, crocodiles and constricting and/or venomous snakes.”

The Muskingum County Police Department was wrongly blamed for this tragic event. Those animals would not have been killed if wild animals were kept in no other place but the wild. 

Logged into Pipe Dream and Facebook

  1. Stenger’s first semester is in the books

    — Pipe Dream sits down with President Harvey Stenger to discuss his first semester at BU and ideas for years to come.

  2. Union closure to displace workers

    — For the roughly 40 unionized Sodexo employees working in the New University Union Food Court and Susquehanna Room, the renovations to the University Unions mean new jobs, and possibly different hours and wages.

  3. Teacher evaluations overlooked by admins

    — Many believe that the Binghamton University’s treatment of teaching evaluations leaves students without a viable avenue to voice their opinions about the classes they take and the instructors who teach them.

  4. Police Watch: May 14, 2012

    — FRIDAY, MAY 4, 11:30 a.m. — A 19-year-old female student reported that she was being harassed by several people from her residence hall, College-in-the-Woods’ Mohawk Hall, said Investigator Patrick Reilly of Binghamton’s New York State University Police. The student said that in December she was harassed by someone in the laundry room of the building, [...]

  5. Student commencement speakers prepare for big day

    — Binghamton University released the names of the three students selected to speak on behalf of their classmates at Sunday’s commencement ceremonies.