A bill aiming to reform New York’s state laws on sexual assault is currently being delayed by Speaker of the New York State Assembly Carl Heastie.
The bill has bipartisan support, with signatures from 92 of the 150 members of the Assembly. Under current New York law, a victim who is voluntarily intoxicated must prove a state of physical helplessness to prosecute sexual assault. Bill A101 would make it illegal to have sex with anyone too intoxicated to consent. Heastie has delayed the Bill from advancing to a full vote on the floor.
“We are actively negotiating this bill and hope to come to an agreement,” said Michael Whyland, a spokesperson for Heastie.
This bill has been the center of debate for six years. The first proposal for a bill to reform the law on incapacitation was in 2019. Manhattan District Attorney Cy Vance wrote a letter to then-New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo arguing that under the law then, if someone is “voluntarily intoxicated,” they cannot be considered too drunk to consent.
Christina Maxwell, a singer and actress from Manhattan, said the voluntary intoxication loophole prevented her from pressing charges after being assaulted at a social gathering in 2020. According to Maxwell, she was too intoxicated to stand. While a test of her hair revealed the presence of gamma-hydroxybutyrate, a drug commonly referred to as the date rape drug, the police could not determine an exact time the drug was ingested. The person she accused was never arrested.
“For some reason, out of all the major crimes in the state, rape is the only one that is treated differently, so the level of intoxication somehow eliminates the fact that a crime existed,” said Lizzie Asher, co-founder of the Justice Without Exclusion coalition, to NBCNY.
The case of Leslie Hunt is also cited in conversations regarding the loophole in state law. Hunt alleges that she was drugged and sexually assaulted by a colleague in 2015. She reported the crime to the New York Police Department, but the department closed her case without an investigation. She argues that the voluntary intoxication loophole prevented her from prosecuting the case because it could not be proven that she was drugged.
According to City and State New York, the numerous Republican sponsors on the bill mean it could theoretically pass even if a majority of Democrats do not vote “yes.”
“I do not pass bills with Republican votes,” Heastie said. “People put the Democrats in the majority, so mentioning that there’s a bunch of Republican sponsors, that’s not of consequence to us on the passage of a bill.”
Following the Cornell 7 case, some lawmakers are attempting to introduce new measures to support student victims. A former Cornell University student, going under the name Jane Doe accused seven members of the university’s Chi Phi chapter of gang raping her after pressuring her into consuming drugs. Cornell’s Chi Phi chapter was barred from campus after the alleged assault. None of the individuals accused in the assault faced criminal charges.
The Cornell Title IX office has concluded its investigation, according to Jane Doe’s complaint. The Ithaca Police Department investigation is ongoing.
“It’s important to keep in mind that survivors of sexual violence seldom receive justice,” wrote Liv Rutherford, a senior majoring in philosophy, politics and law and the president of the Feminist Collective. “When the system is built against survivors, these loopholes in state legislation can both be incredibly impactful for individual cases, as well as easily forgotten.”
FemCo has held events on campus speaking out on pervasive rape culture, including a town hall held earlier this month to discuss campus sexual assault resources. At the meeting, FemCo proposed adding a student advisory board to the Victims Assistance and Rape Crisis Center to represent the interests of student survivors.
“There is no rape without a rapist,” wrote Rutherford. “And there is no amount of alcohol or drug use that excuses someone taking advantage of someone who is incapacitated.”