As the midterm election approaches, Immigration and Customs Enforcement activity is an important issue for voters.
According to a February poll conducted by Siena University, approximately 67 percent of New Yorkers have an unfavorable view of ICE. Further, 67 percent say that ICE enforcement tactics have “gone too far.” Forty-three percent of New Yorkers support deporting immigrants living illegally in the United States, while 35 percent do not.
“The current administration is using ICE as a pawn to make us fear our neighbors, but as students have watched unidentified agents violate people’s due process or act irresponsibly with their use of force, we have become more afraid of ICE than we are of actual criminals,” the Binghamton University College Democrats wrote in a statement to Pipe Dream.
The New York gubernatorial debate between Gov. Kathy Hochul and Republican candidate Bruce Blakeman featured intense discussion about recent ICE activity in New York City after ICE agents shot Oscar Belgal, an undocumented New Yorker, while he was in his vehicle with a 5-year-old child in the backseat on Oct. 8.
The Department of Homeland Security claimed that Belgal, 28, has a criminal past and “rammed” ICE vehicles as they tried to arrest him. Newly released surveillance footage does not show this alleged incident.
“Tonight, I spoke with President Trump and DHS Secretary Mullin about the shooting in Marble Hill,” New York Gov. Kathy Hochul wrote on social media. “I expressed outrage on behalf of New Yorkers and urged them to halt ICE enforcement operations in New York. I also asked that any body camera footage of the shooting be released to the public so we can establish the facts and get to the truth.”
The surveillance footage shows Belgal backing his SUV into a parking spot when officers in plainclothes approached his vehicle with guns drawn. According to New York City Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch, Belgal started to pull the car forward when at least one officer fired seven rounds. He was hit below his left ear and is expected to survive.
According to officials, the 5-year-old, who is believed to be Belgal’s son, is not hurt and is in a relative’s custody.
Belgal’s attorneys have filed a habeas petition, and a federal judge blocked his deportation. In the petition, Belgal’s attorneys said “they believe ICE arrested him without a warrant.”
Belgal is now in custody at Metropolitan Detention Center, Brooklyn.
Blakeman blamed the incident on Hochul’s “sanctuary” policies, saying during the debate that she “invited criminals to come into our state and prey on our communities” and “won’t let local law enforcement cooperate with ICE in an orderly way.”
Hochul signed the “Local Cops, Local Crimes” Act into New York state law in May and put an end to 287(g) agreements — contracts between local police departments and ICE — across the state.
The law and its effect on Broome County’s 287(g) agreement with ICE have been central to the upcoming Broome County Sheriff race as well.
Broome County Sheriff Fred Akshar, along with several sheriffs across the state, filed a lawsuit against Hochul and Attorney General Letitia James for what he called an “egregious act of government overreach.”
Broome County Sheriff candidate Matt Ryan spoke out against this lawsuit and Akshar’s collaboration with ICE in September, after calling Akshar’s relationship with ICE “inappropriate” in March.
ICE activity is also a focal point for many students on Binghamton University’s campus as the midterm election approaches.
Comson Cao, the vice president of the BU College Republicans and a senior majoring in economics, wrote in a statement to Pipe Dream that people on the left are unwilling to denounce violence when it is perpetrated by “criminal illegal aliens.”
“It’s interesting to me how the anti-ICE rhetoric really only took off this year, as there was much less coverage in 2025,” Cao wrote. “Do leftists think Trump replaced all the agents from last year with new Gestapo enthusiasts, or is the better explanation for the chaos the disruptions promoted by leftists against immigration enforcement officers carrying out their duties?”
Further, Cao argued that “expanded ICE presence is obviously good.”
On the other hand, some local and student organizations have organized to spread awareness and protest ICE presence locally.
Humans of ICE, a local immigrant advocacy organization, told Pipe Dream their findings regarding ICE arrests in Broome County. According to their investigations, the majority of people detained by ICE in Broome County entered the United States legally and had work authorization, paid taxes, visas, temporary protected status, pending asylum cases or were U.S. citizens or green card holders. Many were detained while working at outdoor jobsites, including landscaping and roofing.
“ICE has shown that it will fire seven rounds into a vehicle with a five-year-old child as a passenger,” wrote the BU Young Democratic Socialists of America in a statement to Pipe Dream. “Nobody is innocent in the eyes of Trump’s agents of terror. The struggle here on Binghamton University’s campus against ICE is united in the larger struggle to protect not only the hard-working immigrants of this country, but also their children.”
Humans of ICE provided statistics regarding the impact of immigrants in New York communities. According to the Immigration Research Initiative, four out of 10 doctors in the Southern Tier are immigrants. Immigrants generate 26 percent of New York state’s economic output, and 32 percent of business owners in New York are immigrants.
Humans of ICE also told Pipe Dream that those who are able to vote should consider supporting immigrants in their communities.
“We must get ICE out of our communities, whether through protests, legislation, or voting, and we must not look away from our reality,” PULSE wrote in a statement to Pipe Dream. “We cannot afford to bury ourselves away while our communities are actively being targeted, we must pay attention and do our due diligence as members of society.”