Omer Mungan
Close

When I moved from Turkey to Binghamton, some of the first lessons I learned had nothing to do with my classes.

Back home, calling a professor by their first name would have felt deeply disrespectful. Here, some professors insisted on it. Small things I had always considered simply “right” — how to greet an older person, how directly to say no, how long to insist that a guest stay for one more cup of tea — turned out to be lessons my community taught me about how to be good.

We typically treat morality as a private matter. We talk about following our conscience, as if right and wrong were something each of us works out alone. But very little of what we call our values came from quiet, solitary reflection. In Turkish, there is a word, “ayıp,” that roughly means shameful or improper. Children hear it constantly, long before they can explain why something is wrong. That is how most of us learn morality: not from arguments, but from the people around us correcting, praising and showing us, over and over.

This is not a new idea. More than 2,000 years ago, Aristotle argued that “moral virtue comes about as a result of habit.” As he put it, “we become just by doing just acts, temperate by doing temperate acts, brave by doing brave acts.” I find this one of the most practical ideas in all of philosophy. If goodness is a habit, then we don’t simply have or lack it. It is something we practice. And habits are never built in a vacuum — they are built among other people, in families, neighborhoods and communities that give us the chance to practice them.

Those communities also shape what counts as good in the first place. In his 2020 book “The WEIRDest People in the World: How the West Became Psychologically Peculiar and Particularly Prosperous,” Harvard anthropologist Joseph Henrich argues that people from Western, rich, educated, industrialized and democratic societies are “psychologically unusual.” They tend to be more individualistic, more willing to trust and cooperate with strangers and more likely to judge morality by a person’s intentions. Many other cultures place more weight on obligations to family and close relationships.

To me, the lesson is not that one side is right and the other is wrong. It is that both are answers communities have built over centuries. Seeing that should make us more curious about each other, not less. It does not mean anything goes — cruelty is wrong everywhere. But a lot of what we argue about as “morals” is really a difference in how our communities taught us to live.

That is why the weakening of community worries me so much. In 2023, then-U.S. Surgeon General Vivek Murthy declared loneliness an epidemic. His report found that about half of American adults experience loneliness, with health risks comparable to smoking up to 15 cigarettes a day. Americans spent about 20 minutes a day in person with friends in 2020, down from about an hour nearly two decades earlier, and people ages 15 to 24 saw a 70 percent drop.

We usually talk about loneliness as a health crisis. I think it’s also a moral one. It is easy to ignore a neighbor you have never met and much harder to ignore someone who knows your name. When no one really sees us, our sense of responsibility toward others quietly fades. We do not become worse people overnight. We simply lose the places where we used to practice being good.

For many students, college is the first community we get to build as adults. Dorm floors, clubs, team practices and dining hall tables are where the habits Aristotle described actually happen: holding the door for someone, checking on a roommate who has gone quiet, showing up to a friend’s event even when we are tired. But campus also makes it remarkably easy to live alone in a crowd, with headphones on and a screen in front of us, surrounded by thousands of people we never really meet.

Binghamton brings together students from hundreds of different hometowns and dozens of countries, each carrying their own version of “ayıp,” their own sense of what is polite, rude or right. That can be a source of friction. It can also be one of the best parts of college. When those habits meet, we get the rare chance to ask why we believe what we believe, and to borrow the best of what others were taught.

None of us becomes good alone in our rooms. We become good the way Aristotle said we would: by doing good things, among other people, again and again. If we want a better community, we have to start by actually being one.

Omer Mungan is a junior double-majoring in history and philosophy, politics and law.

Views expressed in the opinions pages represent the opinions of the columnists. The only piece that represents the view of the Pipe Dream Editorial Board is the Staff Editorial.