Which characters and personalities have taken over media, movies and pop culture in general? The vast majority are the Tony Montanas, Joe Pescis and Ferris Buellers of the world, and rightfully so! I mean, how could you not be absolutely enamored by these quick-witted, fast-talking and charismatic folks? Each word is delivered with such clear cadence and confidence, whether on the big screen or in an interview.
I intentionally included fictional characters as well as the real-life actor personalities in the aforementioned list, as I believe how we respond to each one reinforces the general status quo of the “idealized” personality.
If we only value extroverted, bigger-than-life personalities on the big screen, then that is likely to translate to pop culture itself. Likewise, if we only value the braggadocious presence of celebrities during public appearances, that is likely to directly shape how society views the “ideal” way to present themselves.
My intention is by no means to deny the existence of these icons, but to suggest that, as a society, maybe we can expand our cultural palette to bring more soft-spoken, introverted celebrities into the light. While they may not be as ferocious, they are just as fun.
If society had more introverted icons, we might shift from trying to emulate the fast-talking, overly confident personality to embracing the subtle charisma of the intentional listener.
While show business and maximalist extroversion go hand-in-hand to some degree, I do believe there is also room for quieter personalities to shine. Or at least not forcing celebrities to put on their maximalist mask at every talk show, interview and public appearance. Perhaps this involves more opportunities for less-pressurized celebrity appearances without a total bombardment of rapid-fire questions, as well as an emphasis on thoughtful, high-quality responses rather than sheer quantity in talk shows and general interview settings.
Although it may seem counterintuitive to everything I have said so far, the emphasis on a personalized, open-ended response is one reason I am always drawn to the electric energy at the Oscars. Even though it is totally over the top, at least for a two-minute period (which is more than most interviews grant), we get to hear what these highly accomplished people genuinely feel about their success and commitment to their livelihoods.
I believe Michael B. Jordan, a self-proclaimed introvert, offers a strong character study of the problematic nature of the extroverted ideal in pop culture and media. As Jordan said in an interview with Vanity Fair, “I’m naturally an introvert. But when the camera’s rolling, I have to turn it on, and that drains a lot out of me. Recharging is a huge thing. Being able to find those moments to decompress and get back to neutral is important.”
Jordan here is not only referencing his cinematic appearances, but practically all public appearances. For example, there is a Vogue interview with Jordan that came out a little while ago in which he is bombarded with 27 questions as he moves from one room to the next, gets a fake haircut and picks out an entire wardrobe. Even though this is less than half of Vogue’s traditional 73, that’s more than I do in the entirety of a day. And all in the span of seven minutes — the media is once again glorifying the maximalist and extroverted presence.
This interview with Jordan isn’t even the worst of it either. Turn on any celebrity talk show, and the writing is all shiny, glazed with witty puns and scripted anecdotes. There is no room for error, silence or mistakes — only constant, in-your-face confidence, without the awkwardness that comes with day-to-day interactions. This affects how we see ourselves and others, possibly pushing us to compare ourselves to unreasonable social ideals that aren’t realistic for anyone.
Every individual has the power to shape the pop-cultural norms around us. Just as votes can shape elections, views, counts and likes can shape the cultural zeitgeist. Therefore, as consumers of media, maybe we ought to show some more love to the conversational and tempered-down content a little more than the 27 questions in seven minutes of content.
Again, removing extroverted entertainment entirely is not possible nor beneficial. However, as a proud introvert myself — seeing TV make room for the quiet reader and saxophone-playing Lisa Simpson, or watching spontaneous, awkward and unscripted interviews always puts the biggest smile on my face. It lets people who aren’t social butterflies feel seen and heard in the media. And perhaps more importantly, it subtly suggests to the quieter folks that there is no reason to pretend to be someone they are not.
On a larger scale, if society values the over-the-top over true character in our celebrities and fictional characters, why wouldn’t that translate to our governments and power dynamics as well? Don’t underestimate the power of fiction in books, movies or TV, for sometimes it reflects our ideals more poignantly than reality itself. And so do its characters.
All of this to say — maybe making a little more room for introverted traits in the cultural atmosphere would have a plethora of benefits. It would greatly ease the pressure off of introverted celebrities themselves, helping to shape the model character of society collectively. It could be a great buffer against the destructive demagogues from seizing power and allowing the more introverted folks to feel more comfortable being themselves in the world!
Jacob Lieser is a junior majoring in philosophy, politics and law.
Views expressed in the opinions pages represent the opinions of the columnists. The only piece that represents the view of the Pipe Dream Editorial Board is the staff editorial.