Deniz Gulay

This year’s midterms demonstrated the need for change in the Republican Party. The first two years of the second Trump administration flipped the political equation from a serious Republican victory to an overwhelming defeat, symbolized by the Democratic victory in Texas, a state that was long considered an unbreakable “red fortress.”

Evidently, there will have to be a change in the party, not only in policies but also in the party program as a whole, to remedy a defeat of this scale. Rather than focusing on individuals, we should look to the general ideological directions Republicans may follow. This approach will be more useful for the media and the public alike to get a clearer sense of the possibilities for change within the party.

With President Trump constitutionally bound to leave office in January 2029, the next two years will therefore be a period when the GOP will need to find its new “flag bearer” to inherit his political mantle. And in that process, the party will have to navigate both internal factionalism and public pressure to have any chance of being competitive in the next presidential election.

The Republican Party’s strategy will have to be consolidation, as the party is far from the media image it is trying to project. The almost six years following Jan. 6, 2021 have been defined by MAGA doctrine becoming the dominant ideology, at the expense of more moderate factions that either broke rank with Trump or were replaced by ideological loyalists. However, at the present moment, neither the party nor its voter base is a monolith. Deciding who becomes the next Republican candidate will come down to finding the most resourceful and appealing personality among party politicians.

Speculating about specific names for potential candidates may be unproductive, but faction dynamics can offer a clearer picture. Assuming that the party will strive for some level of “course change,” we can assume three diverging possibilities, presenting increasingly different circumstances for the 2028 elections.

The first, and probably the most unlikely option would be a return to the pre-Trump moderate establishment. The party line of past Republicans like John McCain and Mitt Romney may be a distant memory now, but let’s not forget that the rise of Trump was also against a dominant party establishment. Just as he rose against the Republican institution and changed the fabric of the GOP, it is not inconceivable that, in reaction to the midterm defeat, a movement may emerge to return the party to an earlier state of moderate conservatism. As unlikely as this possibility is, it is worth keeping in mind the possibility of an “about-face” to return to political centrism.

The second option could be defined in one word as “synthesis,” the restructuring of the conservative ideology spearheaded by Trump. Looking back at the Republican presidential primaries in 2024, the candidates who stood against Trump primarily argued for differences in the manner of his policies, not the ideology itself. This suggests that candidates in the 2028 primaries will take the same approach of adopting Trump’s policies, but making them more presentable, tolerable and less overtly radical. Tough stances on China, immigration and tax cuts would remain, but rage-inciting rhetoric and raids could be sanded off to recapture public support in the South and among the middle class.

The last option is something entirely different from the past two, as it is a window into a future where moderate electoralism collapses in on itself. Undeterred by electoral losses and congressional pushback, the current administration may double down on its invasive and divisive policies to put more pressure on the opposition.

A Republican Party even more radically right-wing and overbearing than today would, in return, create a state of political gridlock that would have an equal and opposite reaction on the Democrats as well. Already disillusioned with their own party establishment over the issues of welfare, labor and Palestine, the democratic socialist group may emerge as the preeminent faction in the Democratic Party in direct response to a GOP burning bridges and salting the earth. In such an environment, we would be looking at a complete metamorphosis of the American political system. As the saying goes, all bets are off at that point.

Three plausible choices now stand on the path to 2028 for the Republican Party. Between reversal, course correction and doubling down, all of these options will require the party to coalesce around, or perhaps even be “whipped” to agree to a united party doctrine. At any rate, it is sensible to assume that beginning with the start of the new House and Senate in January, the GOP will have to navigate a political environment now stacked against the current administration.

More critically, the loss of the South, and especially Texas, signals the unavoidable need for policy change if the GOP wants to see any success. Republicans are facing clear public discontent that has been building up since 2016. Responding to this state of affairs requires consolidating party ranks, or the party will face the oncoming reality of ideological fragmentation without a leader like Trump to hold its factions together.

Deniz Gulay is a senior double-majoring in history and Russian. [ITALICIZE]

Views expressed in the opinions pages represent the opinions of the columnists. The only piece that represents the view of the Pipe Dream Editorial Board is the Staff Editorial. [ITALICIZE]